Video from NBC-2

An 11-month investigation into alleged drink tampering at

Blue Martini bar in North Naples has ended, with no evidence of any suspicious activities, drugs or tampering.

At a news conference Tuesday afternoon, Collier Sheriff’s Sgt. Bryan Sawyer said deputies, including three women and state Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco investigators, worked undercover as patrons, obtaining drink samples and watching for suspicious activities by customers and staff.

In addition, he said, detectives reviewed surveillance tapes. Blood, urine, hair and drinks were tested and 150 patrons, including roughly 50 alleged victims, were interviewed, but no evidence of spiking was found at the bar and restaurant, located at 9114 Strada Place in the upscale Mercato shopping center.

“All reporters had considerable alcohol in large amounts,” Sawyer said of alleged victims, adding that no crimes occurred.

Three people made reports after arrests, he said, citing a man stopped on a drunken driving charge, a female Blue Martini employee arrested in Lee County, and a woman charged with disorderly intoxication. Sawyer said the three blamed Blue Martini.

Since late 2009, they investigated more than 50 reports by patrons who said they became ill, passed out later or inside the bar. Many believed their drinks were tampered with.

Sawyer, who headed the investigation, suggested a Daily News article about three women who filed complaints prompted similar reports. After the article in early November, he said, more than 50 others came forward.

But the initial tip to the Daily News last fall showed that bar management believed it was enough of a problem to meet with employees and urge them to watch patrons and staff.

A private laboratory analyzed hair follicles, which can show drugs for long periods, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement lab tested blood, urine and drink samples.

Detectives reviewed video surveillance tapes and saw no unusual activity. The video, obtained by a subpoena, was over a limited period that didn’t cover most reported incidents in 2009 and early 2010.

Evidence from patrons treated in emergency rooms shortly after the alleged spiking was reviewed, but medical staff found no illicit substances. Patients’ blood-alcohol content ranged from .117- to .228 percent; 08 percent is the level a person is presumed impaired.

Sawyer emphasized the Sheriff’s Office is not closing the door on its investigation, but will continue looking into claims of drink tampering.

“We did a comprehensive check on the reporters,” Sawyer said of the alleged victims, who ranged in age from 21 to 82 and were more than 80 percent women. “We have conducted every reasonable investigative step we could see. … Unfortunately, we haven’t been able to come to a conclusion as to what caused the symptoms of the reporters.”

Blue Martini and Mercato officials worked closely with the Sheriff’s Office and the Mercato started a safety task force that included deputies and state Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco investigators.

The managers of all the Mercato restaurants and businesses came together to address safety issues and share tips about hiring and training employees, preparing and serving food and drinks, said Mike Hoyt, senior vice president of the Lutgert Companies, which manages the Mercato.

“If anything, the silver lining to all this is it helped us get even more focused on getting that high level of safety and comfort to our guests,” Hoyt said, adding that he was grateful the Sheriff’s Office did a thorough investigation.

“It seemed like from the beginning they were serious about digging into this,” he said.

Attempts to reach Blue Martini spokesman and attorney Richard Chosid of Boca Raton were unsuccessful. This summer, he said the allegations led to bad press that hurt business.

The crime, “slipping a Mickey,” isn’t new. It’s occurred for decades, mostly involving well-off bar patrons who later find they were robbed.

Most recently, Palm Beach Shores police headed an investigation into rich men’s drinks being spiked with Rufinol, a date rape drug, in March and April. News reports showed five men in their 50s and 60s blacked out and were robbed of money, watches and jewelry after drinking at bars in Deerfield Beach, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach Shores, Palm Beach and Boca Raton.

They said flirtatious women approached them, they drank and awakened hours later, only to find they were robbed. Police, who obtained video showing one alleged robber, believe more victims exist, but they’re afraid to come forward because they’re married.

Sawyer warned customers to watch their drinks, never leave them unattended, don’t accept drinks from strangers, watch the bartender mix the drink, and don’t drink anything with an unusual odor or taste. He cautioned that patrons should never drink beverages that were moved or suddenly have more or less liquid.

Staff writer Ryan Mills contributed to this report.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

VIDEO/PHOTOS: Blue Martini probe ends, no evidence of drink tampering found

8:48 A.M. UPDATE — Loveland said they also were looking at other ways to improve traffic flow at the Santa Barbara intersection beyond the overpass, which could cost $20 to $30 million to build.

In response to a question, Grubbs said a key to developing any of these projects will be a plan that also includes communities’ density, destination and dedicated funding sources to make sure roads and growth are compatible to support a transit system.

“it is removing barriers and taking the steps necessary” to land development codes to help move road projects like this forward, he said.

Among those in attendance this morning were Lee County Commissioners Tammy Hall and John Manning, commission candidate Carla Johnston and Cape Coral City Councilman Marty McClain.

Johnston asked how the flyovers would help improve Cape’s small commercial tax base. The city is approximately 91 percent residential and 9 percent commercial.

He stressed the overpasses, specifically the one at Santa Barbara, will not hinder traffic flow to businesses because “the turning movements” will still be there, Loveand said.

Grubbs said they looked at various communities, including New Orleans, on how elevated roads impacted cities. Some cities, he said, have started to tear down overpasses because of the adverse impact on businesses.

8:20 A.M. UPDATE ? Major road flyovers and their impact on traffic and economic development of businesses was the topic of Friday’s Cape Coral Council for Progress meeting.

Presentations by Dr. Joe Grubbs of Architecture, Inc., and Dave Loveland from the Lee County Department of Transportation focused on the development of Colonial Boulevard, a major traffic corridor that connects the Cape with the rest of the county.

“It is a vital, economic development engine,” Grubbs said.

Constructing flyovers at major intersections along the road to improve traffic flow was the key component of an intensive study recently. Funding problems will delay the project. But a flyover at Santa Barbara Boulevard and Veteran’s Memorial Parkway in Cape Coral remains a possibility.

Grubbs talked about how the Lee County Commissioners want officials to look at a way at connecting the communities in an effort to achieve “complete streets.”

“The choice boils down to do we want a 50s and 60s solution” to a 21st century issue,” Grubbs said.

Loveland, manager of transportation planning for the county, targeted the Santa Barbara, Veteran’s overpass.

Loveland talked history of a planned east-west corridor that connected Cape Coral with Charlotte County and across the river into Fort Myers that started in the 1970s.

The first piece was the Midpoint Bridge project and the overpass at Del Prado Boulevard and Veteran’s, which occurred in 1997.

Toll money paid for the the remainder of the road development along Veteran’s. An overpass was always planned at Santa Barbara, Loveland said.

Loveland said the long range plan now not only includes an overpass at Santa Barbara, but also at Country Club Boulevard, Skyline Boulevard, Chiquita Boulevard and at Pine Island Road.

“An overpass at Santa Barbara is not going to change access points” to businesses there, Loveland said.

The design for the overpass fits because of the wide median there and the roads to and from businesses, Loveland said.

“In the model for 2030 we are showing 67,000 cars a day at the intersection,” Loveland said. He stressed other models show up to 112,000 vehicles a day at the intersection depending on business development.

County budgeted $2.2 million for the design phase and that is moving forward, Loveland said.

Paying for the project could come from tolls, federal stimulus money or other funding sources.

The county is scheduled to go before the Cape’s transportation committee next month to discuss the plan.

But Loveland stressed because of financial problems the project may not happen before 2015.

Road flyovers topic of Cape Coral Council for Progress meeting

To report a crime or suspicious activity in your neighborhood, call the Naples Police and Fire Department at 213-4844, the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at 774-4434, the Lee County Sheriff’s Office 239-477-1000 or the Marco Island Police Department at 389-5050.

? Berry, berry big bust: 6 Immokalee men caught with 5,000 lbs. of palmetto berries

? New details emerge in Lee County incest case

? South Fort Myers man charged in sales tax fraud ring

? Bonita Springs law firm reports $20,000 stolen from business

? Immokalee man swings knife at man refusing to buy him beer

? Lee County woman charged with child porn, incest

Domestic assault arrests

? Joel Neftali Perez Cardona, 20, of an undisclosed numeric on Honer Avenue, Bonita Springs, was arrested Wednesday by Lee deputies at the Lee County Jail. He was arrested on a capias warrant on a charge of sexual assault by a person older than 18 on a person younger than 12 years old. Details were not immediately available.

? Virginia Lea Clark, 22, of the 4000 block of Dorando Drive, Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies Wednesday at home. Clark was charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon without intent to kill, after reports said she stabbed her live-in boyfriend with a pair of scissors.

? James K. Johnston, 28, of the 2000 block of 50th Terrace S.W., Golden Gate, was arrested by Collier deputies Wednesday at home. Johnston was charged with obstruction of justice and battery/ intentionally causing bodily harm after reports said a verbal argument between him and his girlfriend became physical. Reports said Johnston also took away the woman’s cell phone, to stop her from calling law enforcement.

DUI arrests

? Daisy Nicolas Baltazar, 20, of the 300 block of S. High Tower Avenue, Lehigh Acres, was arrested by Naples police Wednesday near the intersection of Seventh Avenue North and U.S. 41 North. She was also charged with possession of alcohol by someone under 21.

? Guillermo Ortiz Juarez, 30, of the 500 block of 102nd Avenue N., North Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies Tuesday near the 500 block of 100th Avenue N. Ortiz Juarez was also charged with DUI damage to property or person and leaving the scene of an accident/ leaving an unattended vehicle at the scene of an accident.

Drug arrests

? Israel Joe Gutierrez, 34, of the 3000 block of 47th Terrace S.W., Golden Gate, was arrested by Collier deputies Tuesday near the intersection of Pine Street and Jackson Avenue. Gutierrez was charged with possession of cocaine, possession of narcotics paraphernalia and driving with a suspended license.

? Ariel Nicole Loder, 19, of the 17000 block of Butler Road, Fort Myers, was arrested Wednesday by Fort Myers police in Lee County. She was charged with possession of paraphernalia, possession of less than 20 grams of marijuana and possession of an illegal open container of alcohol.

? Justin EdgarleeNichols, 19, of the 3000 block of 35th Avenue West, Bradenton, was arrested by Collier deputies Wednesday near Interstae 75’s mile marker 99. He was charged with possession of a controlled substance and possession of a new legend drug without perscription.

Click here to view the Collier County Sheriff’s Office’s Cold Case Facebook page

Police Beat is compiled and written by the Naples Daily News staff/ contributors from oral and written reports by Naples police, Collier Sheriff‘s Office, Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Marco police and other agencies. Arrests indicate suspicion of crime, not guilt.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Police Beat: Oct. 7, 2010

As much as lightning and torrential rains have wreaked havoc with the high school football schedule early this year, perhaps no school in Southwest Florida has been impacted as much as South Fort Myers.

Two home games washed out in the past month have cost the school as much as $14,000 in revenue, as well as important preparation for district games.

South Fort Myers athletic director Bill Blakemore estimated last weekend’s washed out contest with East Lee County cost the school $9,000-$10,000 in ticket, parking and concession revenue.

That’s on top of the $3,500-$4,000 in parking and concession revenue he said the school lost when it had to shift its preseason game against Barron Collier to Naples three weeks ago because of heavy rains. The schools shared ticket revenue in that contest.

Blakemore said it’s too early in the season to determine if the school will have to cut costs because of the losses.

“We have money put aside in past years in case something like this happens,” Blakemore said. “Hopefully the revenue the rest of the football season will be high enough that it will take care of the expenses the rest of the year.”

A disproportionate amount of rain in the past month has left South?s saturated field no time to drain, said Blakemore and football coach Grant Redhead.

Redhead said it rained nearly 23 straight days at the school through last weekend, with Friday the third straight day of heavy storms.

Blakemore said the school?s principal told him the rain gauge at his nearby home showed four inches of rain on Friday, when there was ankle-high water on the outer thirds of the field.

?We just got an unfair share,? said Blakemore, noting the drainage grates at the outer corners of the field that already were filled to the top before Friday?s evening downpour. ?The (rain) couldn?t drain off Friday night. It was full. The water didn?t have anywhere to go for 12 hours.?

Two more storms Saturday kept the field thick with water, forcing the cancellation of the non-district game with East Lee for safety reasons and to protect the turf, Blakemore said.

(2 of 2)

?You don?t want to just tear up your field in the second week of the season when you?ve got eight more weeks, nine more weeks to go and not be in a playable condition down the road,? Blakemore said. ?(If) we?ve got no grass left in just two weeks, it would have been a mud pit.?

Redhead said a muddy field is a safety concern because players? legs can stick in the muck when making plants and not give when they?re hit.

?It wasn?t worth getting one of their kids out for the season or one of ours,? Redhead said of calling off the game on Saturday afternoon. ?You can fix a field but you can?t fix a kid that quick. If it was a district game, we would have been making it up (Monday).?

Redhead said the cancellation cost his team valuable repetitions at game speed. But he said the 23-2 exhibition win over Barron Collier paid dividends, and he expects Thursday?s home game against improved Cypress Lake to further sharpen his squad for its District 3A-11 opener next Friday against Bishop Verot.

That?s provided, of course, that the dry weather that South Fort Myers enjoyed Sunday and Monday continues this week.

?It was a lot better today,? Redhead said on Monday. ?Two days without rain is a huge difference.?

South Fort Myers opened in 2005.

Reggie Snell, director of construction services for Lee County Schools, said South Fort Myers? field is among the best in the district in terms of quality of turf and maintenance, which is handled by the school. That?s according to Sonny Jungferman, district supervisor of equipment and sites for maintenance services.

?There?s nothing wrong with the football field. It drains relatively well,? Snell said. ?Probably 20 years ago they play that football game. But today everybody is trying to protect the high school athlete. They?re going to err on the side of caution.?

Recent rains wash South’s revenue away

Cape Coral will move forward with adopting a fertilizer ordinance and investigate a septic tank inspection program instead of replacing the Ceitus boat lift, the City Council decided Monday.

The 6-2 vote adopted in principle a management plan for the north spreader canal, which runs north of Pine Island Road along the city?s western edge. The former Ceitus boat lift, removed after a major breach in 2006, separated the canal water from state waters in Matlacha Pass.

The vote gives the council?s conceptual approval to complete the projects, said Jon Iglehart, director of the state?s Department of Environmental Protection office in Fort Myers.

?The details would be worked out in the permitting process,? Iglehart said.

?We?ve got to do what is right for the environment even if it means taking a few chances,? said Councilman Pete Brandt, the council?s point person on the plan. Science shows the projects are better for the environment than replacing the lift, Brandt said.

The plan came out of a task force that involved DEP, the city, Charlotte and Lee counties and environmental stakeholders. Lee and Charlotte counties also will help with projects involving the discharge of storm water into the area.

Lee commissioners are scheduled to vote on the management plan today. Charlotte?s vote is scheduled for Sept. 21.

The city, Lee County and DEP also created a $3.5 million fund to pay for the projects, said city engineer Oliver Clarke. The city and county put in $1.5 million apiece and the DEP $500,000. There is $3.1 million remaining in the account. The projects are projected to cost about $4.3 million. The sewer expansion part of the plan would be funded by assessments on the property receiving the services, Clarke said.

Mayor John Sullivan opposed the plan, as did Councilman Chris Chulakes-Leetz
?We have stakeholders out there who want us to spend our money and bring down a lot of assessments on the people of Cape Coral. I have a big problem with that. It?s like putting a gun to our head,? Sullivan said. ?Basically we?re making an agreement we don?t understand.?

(2 of 2)

The city would have had to replace the lift at a cost of about $4 million if it didn?t agree to the plan and its projects, which include expanding the city?s sewer system into the area.

The city has enough room in its treatment plants to add new sewer customers.

?We have enough capacity there to do the north part of the city,? Public Works Director Chuck Pavlos said. ?I?m talking the whole north of the city, up to about Kismet (Parkway).

The city has several years to comply, so sewers are not coming right away, said City Councilman Kevin McGrail. It could be four or five years, he said.

?Rest assured we will be very sensitive to being cost effective. It pretty much boils down to protecting the water quality in your back yard,? McGrail said.

Five northwest Cape Coral residents spoke for the management plan.

?Our property values depend on a clean environment, as do your tax rolls,? said resident Rick Williams.

Based on the science, the Northwest Cape Coral Neighborhood Association supports the plan, said president Stella Peters.

Cape Coral won’t replace boat lift

Nancy Smith, founder of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, gives a kiss to Chocowa, a gray wolf who lives at the sanctuary, a two and a half acre piece of land off of White Boulevard. Former sanctuary volunteer Susan Cabot Rather died and left $120,000 to the sanctuary. Sanctuary board of directors used the money in April to purchase 20-acres of land on Dove Tree Street in the Golden Gate Estates to be the future site of the sanctuary.

Photo by LEXEY SWALL // Buy this photo

Nancy Smith, founder of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, gives a kiss to Chocowa, a gray wolf who lives at the sanctuary, a two and a half acre piece of land off of White Boulevard. Former sanctuary volunteer Susan Cabot Rather died and left $120,000 to the sanctuary. Sanctuary board of directors used the money in April to purchase 20-acres of land on Dove Tree Street in the Golden Gate Estates to be the future site of the sanctuary.

Shy Wolf Sanctuary

1161 27th Street SW, Naples

For more information or to become a supporter of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, call 455-1698 or see the website www.shywolfsanctuary.com.


The volunteers at Shy Wolf Sanctuary spend a lot of time these days planning. Planning and hoping that the community which has long supported them will continue to come to the aid of nearly 60 animals in their care.

Plans are underway to relocate most of the sanctuary from its current, cramped 21/2-acre quarters to a new 20-acre property the sanctuary was recently able to obtain. Susan Cabot Rather bequeathed the funds for the Sanctuary to purchase the new land, which will be named in memory of her. The full name will be the Shy Wolf Sanctuary Education and Experience Center in Memory of Susan Cabot Rather.

But first, the board of directors must obtain the funding required to make the move.

The Shy Wolf Sanctuary rescues, houses and cares for wolves, wolf-dog hybrids, panthers and a variety of other unwanted animals neglected or abandoned by previous owners. Its purpose is to provide a place for these animals to live out the rest of their often difficult lives. There are about 40 volunteers — and no paid employees — at Shy Wolf.

“As long as they have a good quality of life, we’ll take care of them,” said Mark Scarola, a volunteer and member of the board of directors. “We’re the last resort for these incredible animals who would otherwise be put down.”

The cost of rescue services, vet bills, and basic sanctuary upkeep is staggering, costing more than $108,000 annually. One of the wolves named Timka came to the rescue from west of Gainesville. She had been used for breeding and left to die on an 8-by-10 foot slab of concrete. It took Shy Wolf volunteers three weeks to encourage Timka to stand on her own.

When the Sanctuary took in two wolf pups and Timka came to life. The pups gave Timka the purpose she needed to live.

Another wolf in the Sanctuary’s care named Julie had been purchased for use in a television show. The man who purchased Julie tried to sell her. When he couldn’t make money on Julie, he dumped her at a Brooksville rescue shelter that subsequently went out of business. Shy Wolf Sanctuary stepped in to rescue Julie, who is slowly recovering from her ordeal.

“Whatever happened to Julie scared her half to death and it was so deeply embedded in her psyche, and all this time, she has not been able to be anywhere near a man,” said Shy Wolf Sanctuary board president Nancy Smith.

“We believe she was whipped or yanked or possibly beaten but she is making great strides to be rehabilitated.”

The wolves live securely in enclosures with 8-foot fences and dig wire, which prevents them from tunneling out. Five foxes, five Florida panthers, six prairie dogs, a few tortoises and two rabbits also share space at the Sanctuary. These panthers were also born and raised in captivity, without learning hunting or protection skills, so they, too, cannot survive on their own in the wild.

Like wolves, big cats appear to have a close connection to nature.

“Kiowa, one of the big cats at the Sanctuary, reacted to Hurricane Charlie before it hit,” said Smith. “She began pacing frantically and agitated, like she was trying to get away from something and then suddenly, she stopped pacing.” Smith said she knew the storm wasn’t going to hit Naples when Kiowa suddenly lay down and became instantly relaxed.

The wolves, however, are the main focus of the shelter’s care. Some of them are nearing the end of their lives; others are recovering from horrific treatment at the hands of humans. The Sanctuary is also caring for several wolf puppies rescued from an accidental breeding incident in the Florida Panhandle.

“The owner separated the litter of nine pups from their mother too soon, which suppressed their immune system development and we took in four of those puppies,” said Smith. “Vet bills for the pups have exceeded $7,500 so far, and that’s because they require such extensive care.” Treatment for the pups has included blood transfusions, medication, and extended stays at the emergency vet clinic.

The addition of the pups to the Sanctuary brings the number of wolves there to 36. For the new facility the Sanctuary will need to raise $2 million in donations and in-kind services.

“In addition to monetary contributions, we would love to receive in-kind donations to sponsor various projects that will be required to make the move a reality,” said Scarola. “We’re asking businesses who can help to please consider donating their services for things required to run the facility.”

Some of those needs include contracting services that would help the Sanctuary navigate the process of working with the county for permitting purposes, fencing, staff housing, infrastructure improvements, labor for building enclosures and installing other building structures, electrical contracting and veterinary services. The list goes on.

Scarola says the Sanctuary will also need kitchen equipment, including freezers and refrigerators. The volunteers feed the animals four times a week, a massive undertaking that requires hours of messy manual labor.

Many of the volunteers, including Smith, must regularly cut up dozens of large containers of raw chicken and meat to prepare the more than 3,000 pounds of meat per month the animals consume. That does not include the greens volunteers procure for the turtles and other animals who require roughage in their diets.

Property maintenance is also a considerable expense for the sanctuary.

Something as simple as a donation of a lawn mower makes a big difference in the operating budget, Scarola says. He hopes someone will come forward to donate a new workshop, such as a prefab structure at the new property to store equipment and supplies. Partners and donors will be able to sponsor enclosures and individual wolves among other opportunities to give. The sanctuary is a 501(c)3 organization.

Smith says she hopes that, with help from local universities and contractors, the new Shy Wolf facility can be entirely green. Solar power is an option the group is exploring.

The move cannot come fast enough for the staff and animals that have outgrown the current space. The new facility will enable the Sanctuary to rescue more unwanted animals and increase the common space, among other needs.

With the sheer number of volunteer hours and the cost to run the sanctuary, it’s tempting to ask a question that ruffles feathers among animal lovers: Is all of this worth it to save wolves?

Smith has an answer.

“Responsibility means the ability to respond, and when we acquire an animal, we’re supposed to be making a promise to care for that animal until the end of its life,” she said.

Too often, people who buy exotic animals for pets do not keep that promise, Smith continued. Irresponsible breeders sell wild animals that should never become pets. Buyers ignorant of the work required to care for these animals eventually abandon or mistreat them.

Places like Shy Wolf Sanctuary provide the chain of commitment that should exist. Smith says the Sanctuary’s mission is to provide a home for those animals that have been treated like garbage. Volunteers are quick to point out that animals don’t come as the “good” or “bad” creatures that fairy tales make them out to be.

“Wolves have gotten a bad rap in literature — Three Little Pigs and Red Riding Hood stories — but they really are amazing and have this strong connection with nature,” said Tom Hornyal, a recent volunteer at the sanctuary. “I am astonished at how much this organization can accomplish with so few people – you really can make an immediate impact.”

Smith imparted some of her hard-earned wisdom to her volunteers as they prepared the rest of the feed on this particular day.

“I do not want this message of saving these animals to die with me,” said Smith, who is also a great grandmother. “If just one person gets it and keeps the dream alive, we’ll have done our job.”

As if on cue, just as Smith completed cutting up her last bucket of raw chicken, one of the wolves began to howl. One by one the rest of the wolves joined in for a haunting chorus of baying as if they too, know a change is coming.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

PHOTOS: Shy Wolf Sanctuary hopes to turn new 20-acre site into better home for its animals in need

Nancy Smith, founder of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, gives a kiss to Chocowa, a gray wolf who lives at the sanctuary, a two and a half acre piece of land off of White Boulevard. Former sanctuary volunteer Susan Cabot Rather died and left $120,000 to the sanctuary. Sanctuary board of directors used the money in April to purchase 20-acres of land on Dove Tree Street in the Golden Gate Estates to be the future site of the sanctuary.

Photo by LEXEY SWALL // Buy this photo

Nancy Smith, founder of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, gives a kiss to Chocowa, a gray wolf who lives at the sanctuary, a two and a half acre piece of land off of White Boulevard. Former sanctuary volunteer Susan Cabot Rather died and left $120,000 to the sanctuary. Sanctuary board of directors used the money in April to purchase 20-acres of land on Dove Tree Street in the Golden Gate Estates to be the future site of the sanctuary.

Shy Wolf Sanctuary

1161 27th Street SW, Naples

For more information or to become a supporter of the Shy Wolf Sanctuary, call 455-1698 or see the website www.shywolfsanctuary.com.


The volunteers at Shy Wolf Sanctuary spend a lot of time these days planning. Planning and hoping that the community which has long supported them will continue to come to the aid of nearly 60 animals in their care.

Plans are underway to relocate most of the sanctuary from its current, cramped 21/2-acre quarters to a new 20-acre property the sanctuary was recently able to obtain. Susan Cabot Rather bequeathed the funds for the Sanctuary to purchase the new land, which will be named in memory of her. The full name will be the Shy Wolf Sanctuary Education and Experience Center in Memory of Susan Cabot Rather.

But first, the board of directors must obtain the funding required to make the move.

The Shy Wolf Sanctuary rescues, houses and cares for wolves, wolf-dog hybrids, panthers and a variety of other unwanted animals neglected or abandoned by previous owners. Its purpose is to provide a place for these animals to live out the rest of their often difficult lives. There are about 40 volunteers — and no paid employees — at Shy Wolf.

“As long as they have a good quality of life, we’ll take care of them,” said Mark Scarola, a volunteer and member of the board of directors. “We’re the last resort for these incredible animals who would otherwise be put down.”

The cost of rescue services, vet bills, and basic sanctuary upkeep is staggering, costing more than $108,000 annually. One of the wolves named Timka came to the rescue from west of Gainesville. She had been used for breeding and left to die on an 8-by-10 foot slab of concrete. It took Shy Wolf volunteers three weeks to encourage Timka to stand on her own.

When the Sanctuary took in two wolf pups and Timka came to life. The pups gave Timka the purpose she needed to live.

Another wolf in the Sanctuary’s care named Julie had been purchased for use in a television show. The man who purchased Julie tried to sell her. When he couldn’t make money on Julie, he dumped her at a Brooksville rescue shelter that subsequently went out of business. Shy Wolf Sanctuary stepped in to rescue Julie, who is slowly recovering from her ordeal.

“Whatever happened to Julie scared her half to death and it was so deeply embedded in her psyche, and all this time, she has not been able to be anywhere near a man,” said Shy Wolf Sanctuary board president Nancy Smith.

“We believe she was whipped or yanked or possibly beaten but she is making great strides to be rehabilitated.”

The wolves live securely in enclosures with 8-foot fences and dig wire, which prevents them from tunneling out. Five foxes, five Florida panthers, six prairie dogs, a few tortoises and two rabbits also share space at the Sanctuary. These panthers were also born and raised in captivity, without learning hunting or protection skills, so they, too, cannot survive on their own in the wild.

Like wolves, big cats appear to have a close connection to nature.

“Kiowa, one of the big cats at the Sanctuary, reacted to Hurricane Charlie before it hit,” said Smith. “She began pacing frantically and agitated, like she was trying to get away from something and then suddenly, she stopped pacing.” Smith said she knew the storm wasn’t going to hit Naples when Kiowa suddenly lay down and became instantly relaxed.

The wolves, however, are the main focus of the shelter’s care. Some of them are nearing the end of their lives; others are recovering from horrific treatment at the hands of humans. The Sanctuary is also caring for several wolf puppies rescued from an accidental breeding incident in the Florida Panhandle.

“The owner separated the litter of nine pups from their mother too soon, which suppressed their immune system development and we took in four of those puppies,” said Smith. “Vet bills for the pups have exceeded $7,500 so far, and that’s because they require such extensive care.” Treatment for the pups has included blood transfusions, medication, and extended stays at the emergency vet clinic.

The addition of the pups to the Sanctuary brings the number of wolves there to 36. For the new facility the Sanctuary will need to raise $2 million in donations and in-kind services.

“In addition to monetary contributions, we would love to receive in-kind donations to sponsor various projects that will be required to make the move a reality,” said Scarola. “We’re asking businesses who can help to please consider donating their services for things required to run the facility.”

Some of those needs include contracting services that would help the Sanctuary navigate the process of working with the county for permitting purposes, fencing, staff housing, infrastructure improvements, labor for building enclosures and installing other building structures, electrical contracting and veterinary services. The list goes on.

Scarola says the Sanctuary will also need kitchen equipment, including freezers and refrigerators. The volunteers feed the animals four times a week, a massive undertaking that requires hours of messy manual labor.

Many of the volunteers, including Smith, must regularly cut up dozens of large containers of raw chicken and meat to prepare the more than 3,000 pounds of meat per month the animals consume. That does not include the greens volunteers procure for the turtles and other animals who require roughage in their diets.

Property maintenance is also a considerable expense for the sanctuary.

Something as simple as a donation of a lawn mower makes a big difference in the operating budget, Scarola says. He hopes someone will come forward to donate a new workshop, such as a prefab structure at the new property to store equipment and supplies. Partners and donors will be able to sponsor enclosures and individual wolves among other opportunities to give. The sanctuary is a 501(c)3 organization.

Smith says she hopes that, with help from local universities and contractors, the new Shy Wolf facility can be entirely green. Solar power is an option the group is exploring.

The move cannot come fast enough for the staff and animals that have outgrown the current space. The new facility will enable the Sanctuary to rescue more unwanted animals and increase the common space, among other needs.

With the sheer number of volunteer hours and the cost to run the sanctuary, it’s tempting to ask a question that ruffles feathers among animal lovers: Is all of this worth it to save wolves?

Smith has an answer.

“Responsibility means the ability to respond, and when we acquire an animal, we’re supposed to be making a promise to care for that animal until the end of its life,” she said.

Too often, people who buy exotic animals for pets do not keep that promise, Smith continued. Irresponsible breeders sell wild animals that should never become pets. Buyers ignorant of the work required to care for these animals eventually abandon or mistreat them.

Places like Shy Wolf Sanctuary provide the chain of commitment that should exist. Smith says the Sanctuary’s mission is to provide a home for those animals that have been treated like garbage. Volunteers are quick to point out that animals don’t come as the “good” or “bad” creatures that fairy tales make them out to be.

“Wolves have gotten a bad rap in literature — Three Little Pigs and Red Riding Hood stories — but they really are amazing and have this strong connection with nature,” said Tom Hornyal, a recent volunteer at the sanctuary. “I am astonished at how much this organization can accomplish with so few people – you really can make an immediate impact.”

Smith imparted some of her hard-earned wisdom to her volunteers as they prepared the rest of the feed on this particular day.

“I do not want this message of saving these animals to die with me,” said Smith, who is also a great grandmother. “If just one person gets it and keeps the dream alive, we’ll have done our job.”

As if on cue, just as Smith completed cutting up her last bucket of raw chicken, one of the wolves began to howl. One by one the rest of the wolves joined in for a haunting chorus of baying as if they too, know a change is coming.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

PHOTOS: Shy Wolf Sanctuary hopes to turn new 20-acre site into better home for its animals in need

To report a crime or any suspicious activity in your neighborhood, call the Lee County Sheriff’s Office at 477-1000 or you can remain anonymous and call Crime Stoppers at 332-5555 or 1-800-780-TIPS.

? Heads up housekeeper tip leads to major drug bust

? Bonita Springs man busted for prostitution in March claims exotic dancer stole debit card

Assault of a law enforcement officer

? A 19-year-old Naples woman struck a Collier County sheriff’s deputy, screamed profanities and grabbed the radio from a second deputy’s pocket before she could be handcuffed, according to the Sheriff’s Office.

Candice Lakeye Burgess, 19, of the 2000 block of 10 Ave. NE, Golden Gate Estates, was arrested for battery on a law enforcement officer Monday, according to reports.

After she was placed in double-lock handcuffs and put in the back of the police cruiser, she slipped the handcuffs around her legs to the front of her body. Officers had to place a hobble strap around her legs after securing her arms behind her a second time, according to reports.

Deputies earlier had been dispatched to a residence in the 2000 block of 55th Terrace SW where a man was in the back lanai packing belongings and a woman was inside. The suspect was heard screaming from the rear of the house at someone inside. When approached by a deputy, she screamed profanities and broke free from the officer’s grasp. She struck the deputy in the lower lip with a small purse. She also grabbed the radio microphone from a second deputy’s shirt.

Domestic assault arrests

? A 19-year-old Naples woman struck a police officer, screamed profanities and grabbed the radio from a second officer’s pocket before she could be handcuffed, accoridng to Collier sheriff’s office.

Shaun Patrick Cassidy, 40, of the 1000 block of Clark Court, Naples, was arrested on suspicion of domestic violence by sheriff’s deputies Monday, according to arrest reports. His live-in girlfriend, Deana Newton, had returned to the residence and found her belongings strewn in the bushes and a big kitchen knife stuck in the wood on the front porch. He grabbed her by the neck and she was able to break free.

DUI arrests

? Aurelie Catherine Shuleshko, 61, of the 25000 block of Ballycastle Court, Bonita Springs, was arrested Monday by Lee deputies near U.S. 41 South and Pelican’s Nest Drive in Bonita Springs. She was charged with DUI/first offense.

? Timothy Wayne Weichert, 36, of the 10000 block of Tangerine Road, Fort Myers, was arrested Tuesday by Lee deputies near Spruce Road and San Carlos Boulevard in Fort Myers. He was charged with driving without a valid motorcycle license endorsement, possession of less than 20 grams of marijuana, possession of cocaine and carrying a concealed weapon/brass knuckles.

Grand theft

? An air hammer and fishing rods with a total value of $700 were reported stolen Tuesday from an open garage in the 11000 block of Cherry Street in Bonita Springs.

Police blotter is compiled and written by the Naples Daily News staff/ contributors from oral and written reports by Naples police, Collier Sheriff‘s Office, Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Marco police and other agencies. Arrests indicate suspicion of crime, not guilt.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Police Beat: July 13, 2010

To report a crime or suspicious activity in your neighborhood, call the Naples Police and Fire Department at 213-4844, the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at 774-4434, the Lee County Sheriff’s Office 239-477-1000 or the Marco Island Police Department at 389-5050.

? ‘Run, ma, run’: Mother, son charged with shoplifting

? Collier detectives bust Estates marijuana grow house

? Fingerprint on whiskey bottle lands Marco Island man in jail

? Wrong turn: Woman arrested after parking in handicapped spot

? Teen arrested on drug charges after shooting at ‘invisible people’ with stolen gun

? Money didn’t talk: Man offers bribe to Lee sheriff’s deputy to avoid DUI arrest

? Signature theft: Hall of Fame sports memorabilia reported stolen from Lee County office

? Click here to view the Collier County Sheriff’s Office’s Cold Case Facebook page

Domestic violence arrests

? Miles Maxwell Dacko, 24, of the 5100 block of Teakwood Drive, Golden Gate Estates, was arrested Tuesday by Collier deputies at Teakwood Drive. He was charged with putting his girlfriend in a choke hold and biting her right bicep.

? Lee Marvin Hill, 23, of the 2000 block of Rookery Bay Drive, East Naples, was arrested Tuesday by Collier deputies at Rookery Bay Drive. He was charged with kicking a speaker box at his girlfriend and going after her with a box cutter.

? Christopher Deon Elbert, 20, of the 5500 block of Wilmar Lane, East Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies on Tuesday at 2001 Sunshine Boulevard. He was charged with punching the face of his wife.

Drug arrests

? Patricia Ann Palermo, 46, of Tarpon Springs, was arrested by Collier deputies on Tuesday at the intersection of Estey Avenue and Airport-Pulling Road. She was charged with possession of Xanax, possession of Methadone, possession of narcotic paraphernalia, driving with an unassigned tag, and failure to register a motor vehicle after a traffic stop.

? Thomas C. Simmons, 19, of the first block of Liberty Lane, East Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies on Tuesday at the intersection of 23rd Avenue Southwest and 46th Terrace Southwest. He was charged with possession of Xanax, possession of a controlled substance, and possession of marijuana after a traffic stop.

? Claudine J. Sisca, 38, of the 1500 block of Weybridge Circle, North Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies on Tuesday on U.S. 41 North. She was charged with possession of Lorazepam, possession of oxycodone, and possession of narcotic paraphernalia.

? Michael J. Retino, 31, whose address on Whistlers Cove Circle in East Naples was not released, was arrested by Naples police on Tuesday on Fifth Avenue South. He was charged with possession of cocaine, after the drug was found inside his wallet after he was booked in the Collier County jail on a separate charge.

DUI arrests

? Julia Ann Birdman, 47, of Fort Myers, was arrested Tuesday by Lee deputies on McGregor Boulevard in Fort Myers.

n James T. Koporc, 19, who is homeless in Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies on Tuesday near the intersection of U.S. 41 East and Broward Street.

Police Beat is compiled and written by the Naples Daily News staff/ contributors from oral and written reports by Naples police, Collier Sheriff‘s Office, Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Marco police and other agencies. Arrests indicate suspicion of crime, not guilt.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Police Beat: July 7, 2010

To report a crime or suspicious activity in your neighborhood, call the Naples Police and Fire Department at 213-4844, the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at 774-4434, the Lee County Sheriff’s Office 239-477-1000 or the Marco Island Police Department at 389-5050.

? Deputies: Man stabs business associate after argument

? Deputies: Bonita man accidentally shoots wife while cleaning gun

http://www.naplesnews.com/news/2010/jun/18/teen-charged-circle-k-robbery-immokalee/

Teen charged with Circle K robbery in Immokalee

Domestic assault arrests

? Eduardo Olivares, 23, of the 500 block of 19th Street N., Immokalee, was arrested by Collier deputies Thursday at home. He was charged with battery after reports said he kicked his girlfriend for not cleaning his work shirt.

Drug arrests

? Kenneth William Purkey, 25, of the 5000 block of Rattlesnake hammock Road, East Naples, was arrested by Collier deputies Wednesday near the 4000 block of Biscayne Drive. Purkey was charged with possession of marijuana, possession of narcotics paraphernalia and failure to appear for a driving without a license appearance.

? Craig Allan Smith, 26, of the 17000 block of Caloosa Trace Circle, Fort Myers, was arrested Thursday by Lee deputies near Bonita Beach Road and Imperial Parkway in Bonita Springs. He was charged with possession of more than 20 grams of a controlled substance without a prescription.

Grand theft arrests

? Christian Martinez Santiago, 20, whose Golden Gate Estates address was unavailable, was arrested by Collier deputies Thursday near the 15000 block of Coastal Bay. Martinez Santiago was charged with felony grand theft $300 to $5,000 and burglary of an unoccupied vehicle, after reports said on June 6 he broke into a car in the 15000 block of Indigo Lakes Circles and stole $2584 worth of electronics and cash.

Police Beat is compiled and written by the Naples Daily News staff/ contributors from oral and written reports by Naples police, Collier Sheriff‘s Office, Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Marco police and other agencies. Arrests indicate suspicion of crime, not guilt.

? 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Police Beat: June 18, 2010